Garmin Approach S12
Top PickWhat We Like
- Up to 30 hours in GPS mode
- 42,000-plus courses preloaded
- Just 34 grams on the wrist
- Physical buttons, no touchscreen to fight
Worth Noting
- Monochrome screen, no color hole maps
- Weight
- 1.2 oz
- Display
- Sunlight-readable MIP
- GPS Battery
- Up to 30 hours
- Preloaded Courses
- 42,000+
The Approach S12 has no touchscreen, no color maps and no virtual caddie, and after a few rounds we stopped wishing for any of them. Press one button, pick the course you're standing on, and it gives you front, middle and back along with carries over the bunkers and water in front of you. The display is the part that surprised us: it's a monochrome transflective screen, so it looks flat and gray indoors and gets sharper and easier to read the brighter the sun gets. On a bright tee box it was the clearest thing anyone in the group was holding.
At 34 grams it disappears on the wrist, and the buttons work through a glove without you looking down — we got through a full nine before anyone mentioned the watch, which is the highest praise a golf gadget gets. Garmin lists 30 hours in GPS mode, so it's several rounds between charges, and with 42,000-plus courses preloaded there's nothing to download before you tee off. Score entry takes a couple of presses at the green, and the round uploads to the Garmin Golf app from the parking lot afterwards.
What you give up is everything beyond the yardage. There's no shot tracking unless you add Garmin's CT10 sensors, sold separately, and no notifications, heart rate or color overhead view of the hole. If you want one watch that doubles as a smartwatch, this isn't it — the S44 is. What we keep noticing is how little there is to notice: no menu tree to learn, no battery percentage to check, no fiddling on the first tee.
Bottom line: For most golfers we recommend the Approach S12: accurate front, middle and back yardages, a full weekend of battery, and nothing to learn before the first tee.